The Sovereign Immunity Entitlement of Sunken Foreign Military Wreck Within Indonesian Territorial Water
Hak Kekebalan Kedaulatan atas Bangkai Kapal Militer Asing yang Tenggelam di Wilayah Perairan Indonesia
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.30649/ph.v25i1.329Keywords:
Wrecks of Warship, Restricted Sovereign Immunity, Territorial Waters, SalvageAbstract
The 2014 retrieval of two Dutch warship wrecks from Indonesian waters, remnants of World War II's Battle of Java, sparked legal debate regarding sovereign immunity for sunken warships. The wrecks' disappearance, revealed during a 75th-anniversary commemoration, questions the continued applicability of such immunity in foreign waters. This study examines the wrecks' legal status, particularly their exclusion from the 2001 UNESCO Convention due to their age. Employing juridical-normative research, the study analyses international legal instruments, court decisions, literature, and state practices. Findings suggest that while sovereign immunity persists, its scope is limited. A non-operational wreck serves no military purpose but maintain its identity. The absence of a comprehensive international framework underscores the importance of the Indonesia-Netherlands bilateral agreement in protecting remaining wrecks. The study concludes that increased international cooperation is crucial for addressing legal uncertainties surrounding sovereign wrecks and ensuring their preservation.
Downloads
References
Bailey, Sidney D. Prohibitions and Restraints in War. London: Oxford University Press, 1972.
Baltimore, Crisfield & Onancock Line v. United States, No. 140 F.2d 230 (4th Cir. 1944) (n.d.).
Brownlie, Ian. Principles of Public International Law. 5th ed. Oxford : New York: Clarendon Press ; Oxford University Press, 1998.
Fitzmaurice, Malgosia, David M. Ong, and Panos Merkouris, eds. Research Handbook on International Environmental Law. Cheltenham, UK: Edward Elgar Publishing Limited, 2010.
“Manual of the Laws of Naval War.” Oxford: Institut de droit international, 1913.
Scott, James Brown, ed. Classics of International Law. Vol. 1. 3. Washington: Carnegie Institution, 1913.
Shaw, Malcolm N. International Law. 6th ed. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, 2008.
Tanaka, Yoshifumi. The International Law of the Sea. 2nd ed. Cambridge, United Kingdom: Cambridge University Press, 2015.
Ashley Roach, J. “Sunken Warships and Military Aircraft.” Marine Policy 20, no. 4 (July 1996): 351–54. https://doi.org/10.1016/0308-597X(96)00016-4.
Aust, Anthony. Handbook of International Law. 1st ed. Cambridge University Press, 2005. https://doi.org/10.1017/CBO9780511494123.
Bederman, David J. “Rethinking the Legal Status of Sunken Warships.” Ocean Development & International Law 31, no. 1–2 (January 2000): 97–125. https://doi.org/10.1080/009083200276085.
Caflisch, Lucius. “Submarine Antiquities and the International Law of the Sea.” Netherlands Yearbook of International Law 13 (December 1982): 3–32. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0167676800002993.
Curfman, David. “Thar Be Treasure Here: Rights to Ancient Shipwrecks in International Waters—A New Policy Regime.” Washington University Law Review 86, no. 1 (January 2008): 181.
Forrest, Craig. “A New International Regime for the Protection of Underwater Cultural Heritage.” International and Comparative Law Quarterly 51, no. 3 (July 2002): 511–54. https://doi.org/10.1093/iclq/51.3.511.
GA., I. “‘Sic Utere Tuo Ut Alienum Non Laedas.’” The Michigan Law Review Association 5 (1990).
Garcia, M. R. “The Doctrine of Sovereign Immunity of Foreign States and Its Recent Modifications.” Virginia Law Review 42, no. 3 (1956): 335.
Harris, Jason R. “The Protection Of Sunken Warships As Gravesites At Sea.” Ocean and Coastal Law Journal 7 (2001). http://digitalcommons.mainelaw.maine.edu/oclj/vol7/iss1/11.
Meron, Theodor. Henry’s Wars and Shakespeare’s LawsPerspectives on the Law of War in the Later Middle Ages. Oxford University Press, 1993. https://doi.org/10.1093/acprof:oso/9780198258117.001.0001.
Meskin, Senada. “Legal Status of Warship Wrecks From World War Ii In Indonesian Territorial Waters (Incident Of H.M.A.S. Perth Commercial Salvaging).” Brawijaya Law Journal 2, no. 2 (October 1, 2015): 103–19. https://doi.org/10.21776/ub.blj.2015.002.02.06.
Monfils, Rean, Trevor Gilbert, and Sefanaia Nawadra. “Sunken WWII Shipwrecks of the Pacific and East Asia: The Need for Regional Collaboration to Address the Potential Marine Pollution Threat.” Ocean & Coastal Management 49, no. 9–10 (January 2006): 779–88. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ocecoaman.2006.06.011.
Morgan, M. “United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit: United States v. Jackson, 327 F.3d 273 (4th Cir. 2003).” Capital Defense Journal, 2003.
Neyland, Robert S. “Preserving and Interpreting the Archaeology of the United States Navy.” In International Handbook of Underwater Archaeology, edited by Carol V. Ruppé and Janet F. Barstad, 765–81. Boston, MA: Springer US, 2002. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-1-4615-0535-8_46.
Oppenheim, L., R. Y. Jennings, and Arthur Watts. Oppenheim’s International Law. Vol. 1, Peace. 9th ed. London: Longman, 1996.
Oppenheim, Lassa. International Law: A Treatise. Edited by Lauterpacht. London, 1995.
Oxman, Bernard H. Oxman. “The Regime of Warships Under the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea.” Virginia Journal of International Law 24, no. 4 (1984).
R, Chen. “Bilateral or Multilateral Agreements between States for the Settlement of Dispute over Ownership of Underwater Cultural Heritage: Background, Ownership Clauses, and Implications for China.” China Oceans Law Review, 2022, 111.
Reeves, Jesse S. “Grotius, de Jure Belli Ac Pacis: A Bibliographical Accounts.” American Journal of International Law 19, no. 2 (April 1925): 251–62. https://doi.org/10.2307/2189252.
Regan, Rob. “When Lost Liners Become Found: An Examination of the Effectiveness of Present Maritime Legal and Statutory Regimes for Protecting Historic Wrecks in International Waters with Some Proposals for Change.” Tulane Maritime Law Journal, Regimes for Protecting Historic Wrecks, 29 (2005): 118.
Ronzitti, Natalino. “‘Le Régime Juridique Des Épaves Des Navires de Guerre et Des Navires d’Etat En Droit International.’” Annuaire de l’Institut de Droit International Volume 76. Institut de Droit international, 2015.
Rosenthal, L, and C Raper. “Amoco Cadiz and Limitation of Limitation of Liability for Oil Spill Pollution: Domestic and International Solutions.” Virginia Journal of Natural Resources Law 5, no. 1 (1985).
Vierucci, Luisa. “Le Statut Juridique Des Navires de Guerre Ayant Coulé Dans Des Eaux Étrangères : Le Cas Des Frégates Espagnoles Juno et La Gala Retrouvées Au Large Des Côtes Des Etats-Unis.” Revue Générale de Droit International Public 105 (2001): 705–25.
Walker, Jerry E. “A Contemporary Standard for Determining Title to Sunken Warships: A Tale of Two Vessels and Two Nations.” University of San Fransisco School of Law Maritime Law Journal 12 (Spring 2000).
Winter, Yves, and Joshua Chambers-Letson. “Shipwrecked Sovereignty: Neoliberalism and a Disputed Sunken Treasure.” Political Theory 43, no. 3 (June 2015): 287–311. https://doi.org/10.1177/0090591714555577.
Wandasari, Dwi Arum. “Analisis KerjasamaIndonesia-Belanda Dalam Kasus Hilangnya Kapal De Ruyter, Java, Dan Kortenaerdi Perairan Indonesia.” Journal of International Relations 4 (2018): 115–21.
Besser, Linton, Dan Oakes, and Norman Hermant. “HMAS Perth: WWII Warship Grave Stripped by Salvagers.” ABC Network (blog), December 13, 2013. https://www.abc.net.au/news/2013-12-13/outrage-as-warship-grave-stripped-by-salvagers/5156320.
Hanifan, Aqwam Fiazmi, Arbi Sumandoyo, and Mawa Kresna. “Kerugian Negara Dari Pencurian Kapal Bersejarah.” Tirto (blog), January 25, 2018. https://tirto.id/kerugian-negara-dari-pencurian-kapal-bersejarah-cDND.
Holmes, Oliver, Monica Ulmanu, and Simon Roberts. “The World’s Biggest Grave Robbery: Asia’s Disappearing WWII Shipwrecks.” The Guardian (blog), November 3, 2017. https://www.theguardian.com/world/ng-interactive/2017/nov/03/worlds-biggest-grave-robbery-asias-disappearing-ww2-shipwrecks.
IMO. International Convention On Salvage (1989). https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/F2/140/230/1567148/.
Militaire Fondsen NL. “Karel Doorman Fund.” Accessed September 24, 2024. https://militairefondsen.nl/karel_doorman_fonds/index.php.
Netherlands Navy. “De Ruyter.” Accessed September 24, 2024. https://www.netherlandsnavy.nl/Photo_ruyter.htm.
Netherlands Navy. “De Ruyter-Class Cruiser.” Accessed September 22, 2024. https://www.netherlandsnavy.nl/DeRuyter1.htm.
Netherlands Navy. “‘Java’ (Netherlands Navy).” Accessed September 24, 2024. http://www.netherlandsnavy.nl/Java_his.htm.
Netherlands Navy. “Java-Class Cruisers.” Accessed September 22, 2024. https://www.netherlandsnavy.nl/Javacl.htm.
Oorlogs Graven Stitchting. “Herdenking Slag in de Javazee in Surabaya,” March 1, 2017. https://oorlogsgraven.net/nieuws/artikel/82/herdenking-slag-in-de-javazee-in-surabaya.
Pacific Wrecks. “Hr. Ms. De Ruyter,” September 20, 2023. https://pacificwrecks.com/ship/hrms/de_ruyter.html.
Pieters, J. “Netherlands, Indonesia Team up to Protect Naval Ship Wrecks.” NL Times (blog), July 4, 2018. https://nltimes.nl/2018/07/04/netherlands-indonesia-team-protect-naval-ship-wrecks.
Watson, Ivan, and Kathy Quiano. “Wrecks of Sunken Warships Disappear From Ocean Floor,” December 9, 2016. https://edition.cnn.com/2016/12/08/asia/world-war-two-ships-battle-of-java-sea/index.html.
“1988 U.S.C.C.A.N. 365,” n.d.
Agreement between Australia and the Netherlands concerning Old Dutch Shipwrecks, and Arrangement, ATS No 18 § (1972).
Agreement between the Government of the French Republic and the Government of the United States of America concerning the Wreck of the CSS Alabama (1989).
“Brief Amicus Curiae of Members of Congress on the Proper Construction of the Sunken Military Craft Act, No. 10-10269J United States Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit,” 2010.
Claimant Kingdom of Spain’s Motion to Dismiss or for Summary Judgement (n.d.).
Compact of Free Association, U.S.-Marshall Islands, T.I.A.S. No. 11661 § (1986).
Exchange of Notes between the Government of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland and the Government of Italy regarding the salvage of H.M.S “Spartan” (1952).
“Expedition: Battle of the Java Sea Revisited.” Karel Doorman Foundation, 2016.
Geneva Convention for the Amelioration of the Condition of the Wounded, Sick and Shipwrecked Members of the Armed Forces at Sea (1949).
“H.R. REP. No. 100-514(l), at 3-4 (1988),” n.d.
Huang, Jie. Law of the Sea Reports. American Society of International Law, 2012.
Indonesian Government Regulation Number 1 of 2010 Regarding the Board of Title, Mark of Services, and Mark of Honor (Peraturan Pemerintah Republik Indonesia Nomor 1 Tahun 2010 Tentang Dewan Gelar, Tanda Jasa, Dan Tanda Kehormatan) (2010).
Institute De Droit International. The Legal Regime of Wrecks of Warships and Other State-owned Ships in International Law (2015).
“International Convention for the Unification of Certain Rules Relating to the Immunity of State-Owned Vessels ( Brusel Convention).” UNTC, 1926.
“Joint Verification of the Location and Condition of Hr.Ms. De Ruyter, Java and Kortenaer.” Ministry of Foreign Affair of the Repubic of Indonesia, 2017.
Minister of Transportation Regulation PM 71 of 2013 regarding Salvage and/or Underwater Works (2013).
Ministerie van Buitenlandse, and Ministerie van Onderwijs, Cultuur en Wetenschap. “First Results of Dutch-Indonesian Investigation in the Java Sea Released,” 2017.
Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Indonesia. “Laporan Kinerja 2017 Direktorat Jenderal Amerika Dan Eropa.” Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Indonesia, 2018.
National City Bank of New York v. Republic of China, No. 348 U.S. 356 (1955) (U.S. Supreme Court March 7, 1955).
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), and Office of Public and Constituent Affairs. “Turning to the Sea : America’s Ocean Future,” 1999.
Odyssey Marine Exploration, Inc. v. The Unidentified Shipwrecked Vessel (September 22, 2008).
Office of Ocean Affairs, and US Department of State. “Protection of Sunken Warships, Military Aircraft and Other Sunken Government Property,” n.d.
“Pengangkatan Kerangka Kapal/Pembersihan Alur Pelayaran Tahun 2016.” Kementerian Perhubungan Republik Indonesia, 2016.
“Protection and Management of Historic Military Wrecks Outside UK Territorial Waters, Guidance on How Existing Policies and Legislation Apply to Historic Military Wreck Sites.” Department for Culture Media & Sport and Ministry of Defence United Kingdom, April 2014.
Protection of Military Remains Act 1986 (1986).
“Report of the Joint Expert Meeting on the Appreciation (Track II) of the Dutch Shipwrecks in the Java Sea.” The Hague Netherlands: Ministerie Van Defensie, January 1, 2017.
Law No. 17 of 2008 on Shipping (2008).
Law No. 21 of 1992 on Shipping (1992).
Law No.11 of 2010 on Cultural Heritage (2010).
Law No.34 of 2004 on Indonesian National Army (2004).
Sea Hunt, Inc v Commonwealth of Virginia, No. 221 F 3d 634 (4th Cir 2000) (Court of Appeals for the Forth Circuit 2000).
The Nairobi International Convention on the Removal of Wrecks (2007).
Treaty of Peace U.S. - Japan (1951).
Tucker v. Alexandroff, No. 183 U.S. 424 (U.S. Supreme Court January 6, 1902).
UNESCO. Convention on the Protection of the Underwater Cultural Heritage (2001).
UNGA Res 2625 (XXV), UN Doc A/RES/2625(XXV) § (1970).
United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (1982).
“United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (UNCLOS).” UNTS, 1994.
United States v. Steinmetz 763 F.Supp. 1293, 1299, D.N.J. 1991 (1991).
Vadi, Valentina. “International Law and the Uncertain Fate of Military Sunken Vessels.” Italian Yearbook of International Law 2009 XIX (2010): 253–57.
War Cabinet decision of 10 March 1922 (1992).
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
License
Copyright (c) 2025 All writings published in this journal are personal views of the authors and do not represent the views of this journal and the author's affiliated institutions. Author(s) retain copyrights under the licence of Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International (CC BY-SA 4.0).
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
